Erased: The Destruction of Rosewood, Florida

By Joe Marzo

On the morning of January 1, 1923, Rosewood, Florida was a quiet, self-sufficient Black community tucked into the piney flatwoods of Levy County — a place of painted houses, rose gardens, family farms, church music, and modest prosperity. Seven days later, it was ash and silence. Every building burned to the ground. Its residents scattered into swamps and exile, never to return. At least six Black residents were killed, possibly many more. No one was ever charged with a single crime. And then, for nearly sixty years, the story of Rosewood was simply erased — from the newspapers, from the history books, from public memory. It is one of the most devastating acts of racial violence in American history, and one of the least known.

The Town That Was

Rosewood was settled in 1845, nine miles northeast of Cedar Key on Florida's Gulf Coast. Its name came from the reddish color of cut cedar wood, which the local pencil mills in Cedar Key processed in abundance. The original settlers were a mix of Black and white families, living in relative proximity in the way that rural communities of that era sometimes did — separately but not entirely without connection.

When the cedar trees were mostly exhausted by 1890 and the pencil mills closed, white families largely left for the nearby town of Sumner, where a sawmill operated. The Black residents of Rosewood stayed. By 1900, the town was predominantly African American, and by the early 1920s it was almost entirely so — roughly 200 people, with a single white family, the Wrights, who ran the community's general store.

What remained was a community that had built something real. Rosewood's residents were landowners, farmers, turpentine workers, and tradespeople. Families owned their homes outright. Some had pianos and organs in their living rooms. There were two churches, a school, a sugar mill, a blacksmith shop, and a baseball team. Survivor Robie Mortin, recalling her childhood there at age 79 in 1995, described it simply: "Rosewood was a town where everyone's house was painted. There were roses everywhere you walked. Lovely."

It was not an island of perfect peace — it existed within the violent architecture of Jim Crow Florida, a state that in the years before 1923 had one of the highest lynching rates in the nation. The KKK was strong in Jacksonville and Tampa. Just weeks before Rosewood was destroyed, a white mob in Perry, Florida had burned a Black man named Charles Wright at the stake and then torched that town's Black school, church, Masonic lodge, and homes. And just three years earlier, in 1920, dozens of Black Floridians had been killed in the Ocoee Massacre on Election Night. Rosewood existed in a world that could turn lethal without warning. Its residents knew this. They tried to live anyway.

New Year's Day, 1923: The Lie That Started Everything

The morning of January 1, 1923 was cold on the Gulf Coast. Sarah Carrier, a 51-year-old Rosewood resident, walked to the home of Fannie Taylor in nearby Sumner — as she did regularly, to do the Taylor family's laundry. Whatever she saw or heard that morning, she kept to herself.

Fannie Taylor, a 22-year-old white woman married to James Taylor, a millwright at the Cummer & Sons lumber mill, was found bruised and beaten by a neighbor who heard her screaming. Taylor claimed she had been attacked by a Black man. Word spread instantly through Sumner. Her husband gathered a mob. The Levy County sheriff, Elias Walker, assembled a posse and began searching for the supposed assailant.

The authorities, without any real evidence, quickly settled on a suspect: Jesse Hunter, a Black man who had recently escaped from a prison chain gang. That Hunter had no known connection to Sumner, and that there was no evidence placing him anywhere near Fannie Taylor's home, did not matter. What mattered was the accusation — and a long-established pattern in the Jim Crow South in which accusations by white women against Black men required no proof to set murderous machinery in motion.

What the 1993 Florida state report later documented — pieced together from contemporary accounts and survivor testimony — was that several people in the Sumner community knew or strongly suspected the truth: that Fannie Taylor had not been attacked by a Black stranger at all, but had been beaten by a white man, almost certainly a secret lover, whose identity she was protecting. The false accusation was a cover story. It cost an entire community everything.

The Violence Begins: Days One and Two

The posse's bloodhounds led them not to Jesse Hunter, but to the home of Aaron Carrier, a Black man in Rosewood whose only connection to Hunter was that his aunt, Sarah Carrier, worked for the Taylor family. White men dragged Carrier from his home, tied him to the back of a car, and dragged him through the dirt toward Sumner. Sheriff Walker intervened before Carrier was lynched outright, taking him into protective custody in Gainesville.

The mob moved on to Sam Carter, a Black craftsman and blacksmith. They tortured him until he agreed to lead them to Jesse Hunter's hiding place. Carter led them into the woods. When Hunter failed to appear, a mob member shot Carter. His body was then hung from a tree. It was January 2nd.

Rosewood's residents spent January 3rd and much of January 4th in a state of barely controlled terror. Many hid in the swamps. White men continued to circulate through the area. The town braced itself.

The Battle at the Carrier House

On the evening of January 4th, a mob of 20 to 30 armed white men descended on the home of Sarah Carrier. Inside the house were Sarah, her son Sylvester — a large, physically powerful man known in the community — and a houseful of terrified women and children who had gathered there believing there was safety in numbers.

The mob attempted to force their way in. When Sarah Carrier came to her porch to confront them, they shot and killed her on her own doorstep. What followed was one of the most remarkable acts of self-defense in this dark chapter of American history. Sylvester Carrier — armed, and refusing to surrender to a mob that had just murdered his mother — opened fire. The battle raged through the night. Sylvester killed at least two white men and wounded several others before he too was shot and killed in the early morning hours.

The fact that Black men had fought back and killed white men sent a shockwave of rage through the surrounding counties. It was used to justify everything that followed.

The Destruction: Days Five Through Seven

The mob that reassembled on January 5th was no longer a posse looking for a fugitive. It was a force bent on annihilation. Between 200 and 300 white men — many of them Ku Klux Klan members who had gathered in Gainesville for a large KKK rally the weekend before — descended on Rosewood. They burned houses. They shot at residents fleeing the flames. A 50-year-old widow named Lexie Gordon was shot while trying to escape her burning home. A man named Mingo Williams was shot in the head from a passing car while walking on the road. His only offense, as one account put it, was being Black and visible.

Florida Governor Cary Hardee was aware of what was happening. His response was shaped more by concern for the state's reputation with northern tourists than by any moral urgency. He offered to send the National Guard. Sheriff Walker declined, insisting he had the situation under control. He did not. He could not. Or would not.

By January 7th, the mob returned to finish what they had started, burning whatever remained standing. When the smoke cleared, every Black-owned building in Rosewood had been reduced to ash. The sole structure still standing was the general store of John Wright — the white store owner who had hidden dozens of Black residents in his home throughout the violence, at genuine personal risk to himself and his family.

The Rescue: Brothers and a Train

In the early morning hours of January 6th, two white brothers named Bryce, who worked the Seaboard Air Line Railway, made a decision that saved lives. They drove their train slowly into Rosewood in near-freezing temperatures, and quietly loaded Black women and children into the cars. They did not take men — they feared the appearance of armed Black men on the train would trigger attacks at the stops ahead. The train carried its hidden cargo to depots across north Florida: Otter Creek, Archer, Gainesville, Fernandina Beach. The families who stepped off those trains never went back. Their descendants live in those communities to this day.

The men who remained in Rosewood fled into the surrounding swamps, spending days in cold and terror before they too made their way out. Many survivors, upon arriving in new communities, assumed new identities. They did not speak of what had happened. In the Jim Crow South, being a witness to a massacre was not an asset. It was a liability.

Silence: The Sixty-Year Erasure

In February 1923, a grand jury was convened in Levy County to examine the events at Rosewood. After deliberating, it found insufficient evidence to indict anyone. No one was ever charged. No one was ever prosecuted. No one ever served a single day in jail for any of the murders, the lynchings, the arsons, or the forced displacement of an entire community.

Mainstream newspapers covered the events briefly and then moved on, often framing the violence as a "race riot" — a term that implied mutual combat and shared culpability — rather than what it was: a one-sided massacre of a community that had done nothing wrong.

The survivors and their families kept quiet, partly out of fear, partly out of grief, and partly because no institution in Florida was remotely interested in hearing what they had to say. Rosewood was not taught in schools. It did not appear in Florida history textbooks. The site of the town was reclaimed by brush and trees. For nearly sixty years, an entire community was simply pretended out of existence.

Rediscovery: Gary Moore and the Survivors Speak

In 1982, an investigative reporter named Gary Moore from the St. Petersburg Times drove to the Cedar Key area looking for a story. When he remarked to a local woman on the "gloomy atmosphere" of the region and asked why the area was now all-white when it had once been racially mixed, she replied: "I know what you're digging for. You're trying to get me to talk about that massacre." Moore was immediately consumed. His subsequent articles in the St. Petersburg Times marked the first time Rosewood had received serious public attention since 1923 itself.

Moore's reporting persuaded survivors to speak — people then in their 70s, 80s, and 90s who had spent their entire adult lives carrying the weight of what they had witnessed as children. One of the most important was Arnett Doctor, whose mother had survived the massacre and told her children about Rosewood every Christmas, insisting that the story be kept alive. Doctor became the driving force behind a push for legal redress. He began reaching out to attorneys and to state legislators, demanding that Florida acknowledge what had happened and compensate those who had survived it.

Reparations: Florida Acts

In 1993, the Florida Legislature commissioned a team of historians from Florida State University, Florida A&M University, and the University of Florida to investigate the Rosewood massacre. After nearly a year of research — including interviews with survivors and witnesses, and review of contemporary news accounts and public records — the team delivered a 100-page report with 400 pages of attached documentation. The findings were unambiguous: a community had been destroyed, its residents killed and expelled, by a mob acting on a false accusation. Local and state authorities had known what was happening and had failed to act. No perpetrator had ever been held accountable.

In May 1994, Florida Governor Lawton Chiles signed House Bill 591 — the Rosewood Claims Bill — into law. The legislation awarded $150,000 to each of the nine living survivors who could prove they had owned property in Rosewood at the time of the massacre. It also established a scholarship fund for descendants of Rosewood families to attend Florida state colleges and universities. At least 297 students had received that scholarship by 2020.

The bill is widely regarded as the first legislation in United States history in which a state government provided reparations to Black Americans for an act of racial violence. The amounts were deeply inadequate — survivors and their advocates had sought far more — but the precedent was real. As attorney Martha Barnett, who represented the survivors, said: "Money is often how we make it up to people. They lost the opportunity to have their first, second generation of kids benefit from the middle-class life they had created."

In 1997, director John Singleton brought the story to a wider audience with his film Rosewood, dramatizing the events with a cast led by Ving Rhames and Jon Voight. In 2004, Governor Jeb Bush dedicated a historical marker at the site of John Wright's general store — the only structure that survived — designating it a Florida Heritage Landmark. The marker was subsequently vandalized at least once, shot at from a passing car.

What Rosewood Means

Rosewood was not an isolated event. It occurred during one of the bloodiest periods of racial violence in American history — the years between the end of World War I and the onset of the Great Depression, when Black Americans who had served their country in uniform returned home to find white supremacist violence waiting for them. The Red Summer of 1919 saw racial massacres in 23 cities. The Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921 destroyed the Greenwood District, known as Black Wall Street. Rosewood arrived barely two years later.

What united these events was not randomness but pattern. Again and again, thriving Black communities — communities that had built wealth, property, churches, schools, and civic institutions against every obstacle — were targeted precisely because of their success. As historian Ida B. Wells had documented decades before Rosewood, the accusations that triggered these massacres were almost never about what they claimed to be about. They were about power, and about who was permitted to hold it.

Today, there is no town of Rosewood. There is a stretch of road in Levy County, a historical marker, the ruins of a story slowly being recovered from decades of enforced silence. Survivor Lizzie Jenkins, whose aunt was a schoolteacher in Rosewood, said it plainly: "It has been a struggle telling this story over the years because a lot of people don't want to hear about this kind of history. But Mama told me to keep it alive, so I keep telling it. It's a sad story, but it's one I think everyone needs to hear."

She was right.

Sources

1. Wikipedia — Rosewood Massacre — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosewood_massacre

2. Wikipedia — Rosewood, Florida — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosewood,_Florida

3. HISTORY — Rosewood Massacre Decimates Black Florida Community — https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/january-1/rosewood-massacre-florida-1923

4. HISTORY — Rosewood Massacre: Overview, Facts & Legacy — https://www.history.com/topics/early-20th-century-us/rosewood-massacre

5. Britannica — Rosewood Massacre of 1923 — https://www.britannica.com/topic/Rosewood-riot-of-1923

6. CNN — Rosewood, Florida, Marks 100 Years Since Race Massacre — https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/08/us/rosewood-massacre-florida-what-happened-reaj

7. JSTOR Daily — Remembering the Rosewood Massacre — https://daily.jstor.org/remembering-rosewood-massacre/

8. African American Intellectual History Society — Rosewood Massacre at 100: Black Florida History and White Terror — https://www.aaihs.org/rosewood-massacre-at-100-black-florida-history-and-white-terror/

9. BlackPast.org — Rosewood Massacre (1923) — https://blackpast.org/african-american-history/rosewood-massacre-1923/

10. EBSCO Research Starters — Rosewood Massacre — https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/rosewood-massacre

11. Zinn Education Project — Jan. 1, 1923: Rosewood Massacre — https://www.zinnedproject.org/news/tdih/rosewood-massacre/

12. Remembering Rosewood — Our History — https://www.rememberingrosewood.com/history

13. Florida Department of State — Rosewood Research Guide — https://dos.fl.gov/library-archives/research/explore-our-resources/florida-history-culture-and-heritage/rosewood/

14. Equal Justice Initiative — White Mob Destroys Black Community of Rosewood, Florida — https://calendar.eji.org/racial-injustice/jan/05